quarter pound pb and jelly cookies


What was it, a year ago when I was on my quarter pound cookie obsession?
And vowed that a peanut butter version was next?
I finally got around to doing just that.
Actually I'm kind of glad I waited so long--it made me think of adding a jelly center to the cookie.
Genius right?
I mean if you're going to have a 1/4 pound peanut butter cookie then one should have a touch of jelly in it.
They are almost a 1/4 pound cookie and definitely each cookie is a meal in of itself.


I was going to write a story up along with these cookies, but I don't think anyone is going to read it.
Be honest, I know I wouldn't; I would skip right to the recipe and see if I have the ingredients to make these cookies tonight.
But that's just me.... :-)


Fairly easy to make.
You just have to make a good well in the middle of the cookie for the jam.
Then make sure the edges are well sealed.







Easy right?

quarter pound peanut butter & jelly cookies
print recipe

8 ounces (2 sticks) unsalted butter, cold & grated (use European butter for best results)
3/4 cup granulated sugar
3/4 cup packed dark brown sugar
2 large eggs
1 ts vanilla
1 cup chunky peanut butter (you can use creamy)
3 ¼ cups all purpose flour
3/4 ts sea salt
1 and ¼ ts baking powder
½ ts baking soda

¼ cup more/less of grape jelly (or whatever jelly your prefer)
coarse sugar for rolling the dough balls in

Cook notes:
Why use European butter? It has a higher fat content and lends a better taste/texture to this kind of thick cookie.
I highly suggest rolling your cookie dough balls in coarse sugar before baking. I forgot this step and it was sorely missed.
Keep in mind this is a very dry dough, and is a little hard to mix, so I used my hands for easier mixing.
Keep this dough cold. If you work in hot kitchen, just keep placing it in the fridge to firm up.

In a mixing bowl, using an electric mixer (or by hand, which I prefer), beat butter and both sugars just until creamy. Add the egg and vanilla and beat just until incorporated. Then add in the peanut butter.
In a separate bowl, stir together flour, baking soda, baking powder and salt. When thoroughly mixed, add to the wet batter and stir just until blended. Do NOT overmix at this point. Cover bowl with plastic wrap (really well, we cannot have air getting into this) and chill for a few hours or overnight.
When ready to bake, preheat oven to 375 degrees; divide dough into 12 – 13 big 4 oz lumps. Cut doughball in half, using thumb press down on one side making a little cup/indentation to place the jelly inside. Place a teaspoon or less of jelly in there. Take other half of cookie dough ball, place on top, crimp edges to seal up nicely (see photos).
Once cookie dough ball is stuffed, keep it in a giant golfball shape size; do not press flat!
Roll cookies in coarse sugar.
Place on parchment lined cookie sheets.
If it’s hot in your kitchen you might want to chill the dough balls before baking (chill 20 minutes)
Put the cookies in a 375 degree oven and set timer for 8 minutes. When timer rings, reduce oven temp to 365 degrees, rotate pans and bake another 9-10 minutes.
You know cookies are done when the middle of the cookie appear set. Cookies will still be slightly soft.
Do not look for golden brown edges—this means you overbaked them; only the bottoms should be golden brown. This is a dry cookie and can overbake fast. The cookies will crinkle a bit this is normal.

Makes 12-13 cookies


  1. WOW! That's the only word to describe these hefty beauties. I love peanut butter cookies so much and the jam inside is genius. Thanks for sharing this amazing recipe.

  2. Loverly, ma'am! PB&J Cookie to go, please! :)

  3. These would make the dreaded chore of packing school lunches a lot easier...just pop one of these into a brown bag and that's that!

  4. hello perfection!

    I love that these are filled and that they are PB cookies that you chose to fill. I see so many stuffed choc chip cookies but rarely PB and these....mmmm, so good looking!

    And quarter pounders never looked so good!

  5. I adore your ginormous cookie balls. They always look amazing. Another genius creation!!

  6. I would have read your story! But I do love the sound of these cookies with a big ass glass of milk!

  7. So these are lunch-appropriate, right? (please say yes please say yes please say yes)

  8. love big thick cookies - esp. ones flavored like my favorite sandwich!

  9. This has been officially bookmarked and put on my list of things to make as soon as is humanly possible :) Cookies are totally meant to be a quarter pound.

  10. Woman, I can't bake because it's too dang hot. Send me some cookies!

  11. I would've read the story! Stories are so fun to read on recipe posts. But these cookies still look great, story or no story. Love the jam in the middle but I won't lie, I'd be tempted to throw a peanut butter cup in the middle!

  12. i like a cookie that requires two hands to eat. better a year later than never! :)

  13. Yum, looks like a serious bakery treat!

  14. oh my golly, these are intense. in a i totally want two of them kind of way. three *might* be pushing it. :)

  15. What a genius idea! These lok sinfully delicious Dawn!!!


I love your comments!


Get This